The Disjunctive Question

[Miao.L]

Is it correct to say- [SIZE=-1]I guess you have gone to Madrid, haven't you?

The background of asking this question is that someone is on a journey, for example, then I ask ' have you moved to the next destination Madrid?' So is it also correct to use 'have gone' in this case?

Thanks a lot.


[/SIZE]

 

[paul.moss]

Is it correct to say- [SIZE=-1]I guess you have gone to Madrid, haven't you? [/SIZE]

[SIZE=-1]The background of asking this question is that someone is on a journey, for example, then I ask ' have you moved to the next destination Madrid?' So is it also correct to use 'have gone' in this case?[/SIZE]

[SIZE=-1]Thanks a lot.[/SIZE]

Well, it sounds ok in this context, although I would say: you must be in Madrid now.