If Meat Eaters Acted Like Vegans - cucumber, a cucumber, the cucumber

Joined
Apr 8, 2024
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Russian
Home Country
Russian Federation
Current Location
Russian Federation
In the video If Meat Eaters Acted Like Vegans - episode 35 on Youtube, JP says:
  • This sausage is a meat-based vegetable substitute for cucumber. It's got the taste and the texture of an actual cucumber, with none of the cucumber.
In these two sentences, he says cucumber three times, each of which has a different article: a zero article (1), an indefinite article (2) and a definite article (3).
I don't understand this at all. Did he use them correctly? Why not just use an indefinite article in each of the three instances? Why a different article each time?
 
You seem to have totally missed the humor in that.
 
Yes, they're all correct.

The first and last are about cucumber as a substance. The middle one is about the vegetable itself.
If so, why do the first and last ones differ in the articles? I mean if they're both about cucumber as a substance, why different articles (a zero and a definite ones)?

To the OP: you appear to have another account on this forum. Can you please confirm?
On this particular forum this is my first account.

You seem to have totally missed the humor in that.
Why do you think I seem that way to you?
 
The sentence could end "with no cucumber" and then you would have no article. The form "none of the" requires the article.
 
Back
Top