[Grammar] She told me, "I am happy".

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rollercoaster1

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2015
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Urdu
Home Country
Pakistan
Current Location
Pakistan
She told me, "I am happy". Direct speech.
She told me she is happy. Indirect speech. (If she is still happy since the time she told me. Suppose she told me half hour ago.)

She told me, "I am happy". Direct speech.
She told me that she was happy. Indirect speech. (If she is no longer happy, not happy now, or it's the other day I am telling someone about her.)

Have I made any mistake?
 
She told me, "I am happy" ​is direct speech.
She told me she is happy ​is indirect speech. (Is she is still happy since when she told me? Suppose she told me half an hour ago.)

Then she might not be happy now. But she probably is. It implies that she said it recently and that there's no reason to think she's not happy anymore.

She told me, "I am happy" is direct speech.

That's what you said at the top. It's fine.

She told me that she was happy
​is indirect speech that means she is no longer happy or didn't say it recently.

Have I made any mistakes?

No. It's clear that you understand the difference.
I made the changes in red because we encourage students to use full sentences here.
 
I made the changes in red because we encourage students to use full sentences here.

I am sorry I don't want to be disrespectful but all your corrections were and are unnecessary. I can't argue about 'Have I made any mistakes', but my sentence is also correct.
Do you ever say 'Have you gone through any miseries, or 'Do you have any problems'?

She told me, "I am happy" is direct speech.
This sentence right above is confusing, isn't it? This direct speech indicates that 'is direct speech' is part of the sentence, when it's not at all. I found it better and sensible to end the sentence where it needed and defined it as what speech it was.
 
Last edited:
By the way, we don't normally use the verb tell to quote direct speech. You can use the verb say.

She said "I'm happy."
"I'm happy," she said.
 
I am sorry I don't want to be disrespectful but all your corrections were and are unnecessary. I can't argue about 'Have I made any mistakes', but my sentence is also correct.
Do you ever say 'Have you gone through any miseries, or 'Do you have any problems'?

She told me, "I am happy" is direct speech.
This sentence right above is confusing, isn't it? This direct speech indicates that 'is direct speech' is part of the sentence, when it's not at all. I found it better and sensible to end the sentence where it needed and defined it as what speech it was.
Direct speech isn't a sentence. Neither is Indirect speech. See the other sentence corrections as well.
 
By the way, we don't normally use the verb tell to quote direct speech. You can use the verb say.

She said "I'm happy."
"I'm happy," she said.

Thanks for pointing out. I am aware of that, I just missed it out there.
 
I would say it differently, thus:

"I am happy" is direct speech.
She told me she is happy. (Indirect speech.)

:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top